return to worldwidereview.com, the home of critical reviews

Lucas Moodysson's A Hole in My Heart, a film on DVD

From:     blp
Category: Life
Date:     07 August 2006
Time:     05:52 PM

Review:

A gothy industrial music fan teen stews in his room while his lame dad, a former heavy metal musician, makes a messy porno film in the sitting room of their 
one bed flat. There's a girl who says she's wanted to be a porno actress since she was 12. She's like a really really stupid Big Brother contestant and at one 
point has a little cry because she's been rejected by Big Brother. The male porno lead is a handsomely goofy looking guy called Geko with a mild sadistic 
side. It's shot on video, mostly in a flat modern verité style, but then cuts frequently to more artful constructions: gruesome shots of cosmetic surgery on a 
vagina, bodily organs pumping, GI Joe and Barbie dolls chatting in the actors voices and having sex, a rubber vagina and arsehole. There are also a lot of 
sequences where the cuts go haywire and the actors seem to be involved in some sort of far worse ordeal than anything the intelligible bits convey. At one 
point the goth kid seems to shoot his dad in the head with an airgun. Then they sit on the bed chatting, the dad's head covered in drying blood. I'm not 
making it sound good am I? I hope not. It's not. It's very very bad indeed. Moodysson can't seem to face the implications of his own subject matter. He picks 
the ostensibly most unbearable, hellish situation he can think of, then doesn't let himself imagine it at all. The quick cuts aren't challenging, they're a 
wretched inability to watch the situation for long enough to let it go anywhere interesting - and as anyone who's spent an afternoon mucking about with 
editing software knows, ten-a-penny artistically. Instead, he moves his characters around like dolls themselves, making them say whatever's convenient to 
his arty notions, succeeding finally, only in sentimentalising all of them, showing them all to be implausibly articulate vocalisers of their inner pain - my mum 
this, my dad that. People think this guy is good. Why? Haven't they ever seen anything that actually is? 


return to worldwidereview.com, the home of critical reviews